COMBATSIM.COM: The Ultimate Combat Simulation and Strategy Gamers' Resource.
 

 
Fighting Steel
by Eric "Snacko" Marlow
 

Summary

I'm a bit torn when sizing up Fighting Steel. While I applaud the developer's attempt at accuracy and realism in constructing the ships database, the AI, and the physical modeling aspects, I am disheartened by some of the choices that where made early in the development cycle.

The need for first-person gunnery/torpedo targeting, the lack of a radar station, and the necessity for more robust campaign engine might damage this game by not allowing a fuller game play experience. It is that fuller experience that will determine enjoyment over the long term, and at the moment Fighting Steel is weak in this dimension.

On the other hand, I had a first-rate time constructing missions and then playing them out as I saw fit. I rather liked playing historical missions and determining if my maneuver skills would have given me an advantage.

Although it's tough for me to overlook the problems with the software, what's included in the box is an enjoyable simulation. Although many of the features I had hoped to make it into this sim probably will never be incorporated, I feel confident that SSI's continued support of this product will allow it to stay on my hard drive for some time to come.

Here are some of my parting shots.. er, thoughts:

High Points:

  • Mission Builder
  • Available Assets
  • Realistic Environment and Feel
  • Manual

Low Points:

  • Lack of Control Over Certain Game Play Aspects
  • Graphics a Little Behind the Times
  • Some Bugs

Click to continue

 

Battleship Rolls Over
A Battleship Rolls Over

Ratings

  • Core Rating: 88%
  • Game Play: 80%
  • Graphics: 70%
  • Sound: 75%
  • Manual: 92%
  • Intelligence/AI: 88%
  • User Interface: 88%
  • Mission Planner: 90%
  • Fun Factor: 80%
  • Learning Curve (in hours): 2-3 hours

Overall Rating: 83%

Test System

  • Pentium III 500
  • Windows 98
  • 256MB RAM
  • Diamond Monster 2 SLI
  • Diamond V550 TNT AGP
  • Turtle Beach Montego II PCI
  • Mitsumi 32x CD-ROM
  • Latest drivers on all ;-)

Download Snacko's custom mission:
The Battle of Vella Lavella

Download the v 1.02 Patch. 1.3 MB to take care of many small issues and crashes.

Download the Fighting Steel Demo 23 MB.

Cruise the Fighting Steel web site.

Join a discussion forum on this article by clicking   HERE.

 

Copyright © 1997 - 2000 COMBATSIM.COM, INC. All Rights Reserved.

Last Updated July 8th, 1999

© 2014 COMBATSIM.COM - All Rights Reserved